Friday, May 16, 2025

3 Best Home Buys in Cambria Right Now (May 2025)



If you’re house hunting in Cambria right now, there’s a mix of coastal charm, hillside privacy, and turnkey homes on the market. But a few listings stand out for their price, layout, location, or upside potential. Here are the three best opportunities on the market this May, based on recent sales and active inventory.

953 Sheffield St – $899,000

4 bed / 3 bath | 1,350 sq ft | $665/sq ft
This fully renovated West Village home checks nearly every box. It’s a short walk to Main Street, has a versatile 4-bedroom layout, and shows like a new build. The open-concept great room, vaulted ceilings, and sunlit deck give it a light, modern feel.

  • Primary suite with spa-style bathroom
  • Separate lower-level bed and bath (ideal for guests or rental)
  • Attached 2-car garage and updated systems throughout

💡 Buyer Insight: Recent comp at 1810 Melrose (3/2.5, 1,631 sq ft) closed for $1.08M. Sheffield is slightly smaller but newer in feel and $180K less. Best value in Cambria under $900K.

2918 Burton Dr – $865,000

3 bed / 2 bath | 1,650 sq ft | $524/sq ft
This Lodge Hill home offers good size and a livable floor plan with a main-level primary suite and direct backyard spa access. The bonus shed in the yard adds workspace or studio potential, and the backyard has room to stretch out or garden.

  • Brick fireplace and cozy living area
  • Walk-in closet, ceiling fans, updated windows
  • Close to East Village and hiking trails

💡 Buyer Insight: At just $524 per square foot, this is among the lowest in Cambria right now for a 3-bed home. It’s a solid long-term option for buyers who want space and flexibility, not just finishes.

2965 Wood Dr – $969,000

3 bed / 2 bath | 1,500 sq ft | $646/sq ft
Single-level homes are hard to find in Cambria—this one is move-in ready and located on a sunny, level street just steps from Cambria Pines Lodge. New flooring and fresh carpet make it turnkey for immediate occupancy.

  • Open layout with large back deck
  • Updated flooring and appliances
  • Low-maintenance lot, near shops and restaurants

💡 Buyer Insight: Comps like 1990 Dorking (1,700 sq ft) sold for $989K. This one offers better layout efficiency and is easier to maintain, ideal for retirees or downsizers looking for minimal stairs.

Recent Sales Helping Define Value

  • 1810 Melrose – Sold for $1.08M, 1,631 sq ft, excellent updates
  • 1990 Dorking – Sold for $989K, 1,700 sq ft, post-and-beam charm
  • 5140 Guildford – 560 sq ft cottage, closed at $690K
  • 1887 Downing – 2 bed, 1,542 sq ft, sold at $750K

The active listings above are all pricing smartly based on these comps, offering solid value for their location, size, and condition.

Bottom Line

Cambria’s market is active but not overheated. Buyers who act quickly can still find homes with long-term upside or immediate lifestyle payoff. Whether you want a low-maintenance beach getaway, a multi-generational floor plan, or a single-level forever home, these three listings are the ones to watch right now.

Want to schedule a tour or ask about recent disclosures? Let’s talk.

No comments:

Post a Comment